Alterations continue on an ordinance to regulate data centers in unincorporated areas of Shelby County, as commissioners approved an amended ordinance that nearly mirrors a similar ordinance under consideration by the Memphis City Council.
Shelby County Commissioners advanced the latest version of the joint ordinance 5-0, with five members abstaining during the Wednesday, Nov. 18 committee meetings.
Voting in favor were Amber Huett-Garcia, Karen Streeter, LaShanta Rudd, Will Richardson and Chairwoman Shante Avant. Commissioners Michele Dial, Derek Mills, Henri Brooks, Rhonda OโDell and Erika Sugarmon abstained.
The amended ordinance cleans up language from the previous version. For example, โcity engineersโ will be referred to by their equivalent county position. There are bound to be legal differences too. Any contradictions will need to be ironed out for Land Use Control Board approval.
โThere are a few sections where we are making sure that state and federal law allows us to do some of the regulations,โ said sponsor Huett-Garcia.
Although unregulated locally, certain aspects of data center operations are subject to federal and state review. Pollution is a good example. The Environmental Protection Agency sets the standards for CO2, lead and other pollutants. County health agencies are responsible for enforcing those standards through fines and other penalties.
Noise pollution, meanwhile, could be addressed through the County Powers Act. The state law allows counties to address issues normally reserved for municipalities.
โThe County Powers Act is a different statute altogether. There are certain things that have to go through zoning, but there are certain things above and beyond what you can do through a zoning act that would have to go through the county powers act. One of them would potentially be noise regulation, for instance,โ said Shelby County attorney Craig Barnes.

The joint city/county LUCB vote is scheduled for Dec. 3. Memphis City Council members passed their working draft on Nov. 4. In broad strokes, the ordinance is the sum of three separate proposals: the progressive use of non-carbon based power and closed loop water cooling systems; the creation of a tiered review based on power capacity; fold the regulations into the unified development code.
A third and final vote on the commissionโs data center ordinance could come as soon as Dec. 6.
The city is currently observing a 135-day moratorium on issuing new data center applications. The pause was included in its data center ordinance to give council members time to fine tune a final version. It is also a window of opportunity for public outreach.
Huett-Garcia recently took part in a town hall with councilman Philip Spinosa to address concerns about data centers. Answers to questions submitted by the public are expected in the next couple of days.
โThe inclusivity of trying to make sure we are one, being a good participant with our community and listening to what they have to say, but also what is in the bounds for county government versus city government,โ complimented Avant.
One glaring difference between both proposals is a moratorium.
During public comments, community activist Keshaun Pearson pointed out that the moratorium under consideration by the commission would expire with the passage of a final ordinance. The executive director of environmental justice nonprofit Memphis Community Against Pollution is the younger brother of 86th District state Rep. Justin Pearson.
Brooks, whose proposal calls for a 12-month moratorium, seemed surprised by the revelation. The commissioner later pulled her proposal for a 12- month pause during the meeting to await the results of the LUCB vote slated for Dec. 6. It could also see further changes.
In addition to extra time, a moratorium will also allow the county to judge the impacts of a newly passed ordinance. There are also unanswered questions that havenโt been addressed in either ordinance, like behind-the-meter power generation, for example.
By producing power on site or at a nearby facility, data center operators can bypass local power grids. This could allow regulators to not aggregate pollution data from the tech facilities.
โThere is a necessity for a pause and addressing behind-the-meter generation, which XAI has shown us, companies will continue to do. That is not addressed here in the document,โ said Pearson.
โOther gapsโ noted by Pearson include clarity on power generation, battery storage and wildlife preservation.
โThe necessity for a moratorium is already precedent with what the city council has passed. All around the country, folks understand that in order to get regulations done the right way, we have to take our time,โ said Pearson.
